# Pre-registration: how old are open job postings on company career sites? Written 2026-11-10, before any posting date in the data was looked at. At the time of writing, the index build had reported only counts of employers and jobs per platform. No date field had been read, summarised or plotted. ## Background Advice to job seekers often treats the age of a posting as a warning sign, for example that a posting open for more than 30 days may not be a real opening. This analysis measures how old open postings actually are on employers' own career sites, on one day. It does not measure whether a posting is real. Age is the only thing measured. ## Data One snapshot, built on 2026-11-10 by the `career-site-jobs` index build (`actors/career-site-jobs/scripts/build_index.js`). For each employer job board in the directory, the build reads the platform's public job feed once and records, per open posting: title, locations, workplace type, and the posting date the platform reports. - **Directory:** job board addresses found in four Common Crawl snapshots (CC-MAIN-2026-30, -34, -39, -43), kept when the board's feed answered with at least one open posting. - **Posting age:** 2026-11-10 minus the posting date, in whole days. - **Platforms with a posting date for every posting ("dated platforms"):** Greenhouse, Lever, Ashby, SmartRecruiters, Recruitee, Teamtailor, Personio, Breezy HR. - **Workday:** the listing says "Posted N Days Ago" up to 30 days and "Posted 30+ Days Ago" after that. Workday postings are therefore used only for the share older than 30 days. A Workday posting with no date in the index counts as older than 30 days. - **Left out:** BambooHR, Rippling and Pinpoint (their listings carry no posting date) and Workable (not in this snapshot, because its feed rate-limited the build). ## Rules fixed in advance - **Exclusions:** a posting dated after 2026-11-10 or before 2005-01-01 is dropped and counted. Nothing else is dropped. - **Main summary:** all postings pooled, so an employer with many postings counts for more. - **Second summary:** one value per employer (that employer's share of postings older than the threshold), then the median across employers. Reported beside the main summary for every question. - **Uncertainty:** bootstrap 95% ranges, 2,000 resamples of whole employers, because one employer's postings are not independent of each other. - **Employer size groups:** small = fewer than 10 open postings, large = 100 or more. ## Questions | # | Question | What would count as yes | |---|---|---| | 1 | Is the typical open posting less than a month old? | The median age of postings on dated platforms is 30 days or less. | | 2 | Are postings older than 90 days uncommon? | Fewer than 10% of postings on dated platforms are older than 90 days. | | 3 | Does the answer depend on the hiring platform? | Among dated platforms with at least 200 employers, the highest share older than 90 days is at least twice the lowest, and their 95% ranges do not overlap. | | 4 | Do large employers have older postings than small ones? | The share older than 90 days differs by at least 5 percentage points between large and small employers, and the 95% ranges do not overlap. | | 5 | Does Workday look like the dated platforms at the 30-day mark? | The share of Workday postings older than 30 days is within 10 percentage points of the share on dated platforms. | ## Known limits, stated before the results - A posting date is what the platform reports. An employer can close a posting and post it again, which resets the date, so ages are a lower bound on how long a role has been open. - Some postings are deliberately permanent ("general application", talent pools). - The directory is not a sample of all employers. It contains boards that Common Crawl happened to visit on 13 platforms, which lean toward technology companies and toward the United States and Europe. - One day is one day. Hiring is seasonal. Anything examined beyond these five questions will be labelled in the post as decided after the results. ## Addendum, 2026-11-10, still before any posting date was read While looking for published figures to compare against, I found one that measures nearly the same thing on a different source. Clarify Capital reports scraping 176,268 job listings from Indeed in February 2026 and finding that roughly one in seven had been active for 30 days or more (https://clarifycapital.com/ghost-jobs-2026; figure taken from a search summary and still to be checked against the page itself). That adds one question: | # | Question | What would count as yes | |---|---|---| | 6 | Is the share of postings older than 30 days on employers' own career sites close to the roughly one in seven reported for Indeed? | The share on dated platforms is between 9% and 19%. |